The 5 Devastating Effects of Supervisor Mistreatment 

When it comes to leadership in big business, there exists an often overlooked but profoundly damaging issue: supervisor mistreatment. This form of workplace injustice can have far-reaching consequences, not only for the individuals directly affected but also for the entire organization. Recently, we released “The State of the Workplace Injustice Report,” which delves into the various facets of workplace mistreatment. This report aims to shed light on the severe impact of supervisor mistreatment and urge leaders in corporate America to take decisive action.

The Unseen Consequences of Supervisor Mistreatment

Have you ever considered the real impact of how supervisors treat their subordinates? Supervisor mistreatment can manifest in various forms, including verbal abuse, unreasonable demands, and favoritism. These behaviors create a toxic work environment that stifles productivity and erodes employee morale. In this blog, we will explore the five devastating effects of supervisor mistreatment as highlighted in the report.

1. Decline in Employee Mental Health

Supervisor mistreatment takes a significant toll on employees’ mental health. Constant criticism, unrealistic expectations, and lack of support can lead to stress, anxiety, and depression. Employees subjected to such treatment often feel trapped and helpless, which can severely impact their overall well-being.

A Question to Consider: Have you noticed a decline in your employees’ mental health? Could it be linked to how their direct supervisors treat them?

2. Decreased Job Satisfaction

When employees face mistreatment from their supervisors, their job satisfaction plummets. They no longer find joy or fulfillment in their work, leading to disengagement and a lack of motivation. This decline in job satisfaction can result in decreased productivity and higher turnover rates.

Question to Consider: Do your employees seem disengaged or unmotivated? Is their dissatisfaction related to their interactions with their supervisors?

3. Increased Absenteeism and Turnover

The stress and dissatisfaction resulting from supervisor mistreatment often lead to increased absenteeism. Employees may take more sick days or leave the organization altogether to escape the toxic environment. High turnover rates not only disrupt operations but also incur significant recruitment and training costs.

Question to Consider: Have you observed a rise in absenteeism or turnover in your organization? Could supervisor mistreatment be a contributing factor?

4. Erosion of Trust and Team Cohesion

Supervisor mistreatment erodes trust between employees and management. When employees feel unsupported or mistreated, they are less likely to trust their supervisors or the organization as a whole. This lack of trust can lead to poor team cohesion, as employees become reluctant to collaborate or communicate openly.

Question to Consider: Is there a lack of trust and cohesion within your teams? How might supervisor behavior be influencing this dynamic?

5. Damage to Organizational Reputation

The effects of supervisor mistreatment extend beyond the internal environment. Word of mouth spreads, and an organization known for poor employee treatment will struggle to attract top talent. Additionally, a tarnished reputation can impact relationships with clients, partners, and stakeholders.

Question to Consider: How is your organization’s reputation perceived externally? Are you facing challenges in attracting and retaining top talent due to internal issues?

Taking Action Against Supervisor Mistreatment

The insights from “The State of the Workplace Injustice Report” underscore the urgent need for leaders to address supervisor mistreatment. Here are some steps you can take:

  1. Implement Clear Policies: Establish and enforce policies that define acceptable and unacceptable behaviors for supervisors. Ensure these policies are communicated effectively throughout the organization.
  2. Provide Training and Support: Regularly train supervisors on effective leadership, communication, and conflict resolution skills. Offer support resources for employees who experience mistreatment.
  3. Foster an Open Culture: Encourage open communication and provide safe channels for employees to report mistreatment without fear of retaliation.
  4. Hold Supervisors Accountable: Monitor supervisor behavior and hold them accountable for their actions. Address any reports of mistreatment promptly and fairly.


Supervisor mistreatment is a serious issue that can have devastating effects on individuals and organizations. As corporate leaders, we have a responsibility to create a healthy, supportive, and respectful work environment. By addressing supervisor mistreatment, we can enhance employee well-being, improve job satisfaction, and foster a positive organizational culture.

What are your thoughts? Share your experiences and tips for addressing workplace injustice in the comments below. Let’s keep the conversation going and create a future where all voices can be heard. If you’re looking for a speaker to inspire and guide your organization toward a healthier company culture, consider booking me for your next event. Also, don’t forget to connect with me on LinkedIn.

The fight against workplace injustice begins with each of us. Let’s take the first step by downloading “The State of the Workplace Injustice Report”  and implementing its recommendations to create a fairer and more just workplace for all.



Recent Posts

Why We Need Zero Tolerance for Workplace Harassment

Workplace harassment is a pervasive issue that continues to plague organizations across various industries. It undermines employee morale, disrupts productivity, and tarnishes businesses’ reputations. Last month, we released “The State of the Workplace Injustice Report,”

Read More »

Five Ways to Identify Disengaged Employees

Disengaged employees are like a slow poison to an organization. Their lack of enthusiasm, motivation, and commitment can have a ripple effect, impacting productivity, morale, and ultimately, the bottom line. In the recently released “The

Read More »